Goats, Bees and Spies – Redux

The farm at Dooneen

This post was first published in October 2013. Since then I have found more material, so have decided to update it.

The non-fiction book, White Goats and Black Bees by Donald Grant is set on the Sheep’s Head. Donald and Mary Grant, a couple of journalists based in New York, impulsively decided to jump off the career treadmill and become farmers in Ireland in the 1960’s. They bought a small acreage on the Sheep’s Head, where they raised goats and ducks, cultivated an enormous vegetable garden, and by degrees and sheer hard work turned themselves into ‘peasants’.

This out-of-print book was drawn to my attention by my friend, Aideen, whose father, while in New York, had encouraged the Grants to consider West Cork. Aideen visited the Grants as a young woman and still has memories of their gorse wine.

Dooneen, on the Sheep’s Head – this was the view the Grants looked out on. It could be fierce and desolate in the winter

As a Back to the Land narrative, this is a classic. Earnest urban professionals consulting Department of Agriculture pamphlets, conducting slug patrols, keenly observing the social structure of their goat herd and duck flock, battling the wild Atlantic storms, making cheese and smoking hams: this is the kind of thing that sent thousands of idealistic young people into communes all over the world, or in the case of Ireland, into the hills behind Ballydehob. The need to be accepted by the locals, a thread that appears in so many Year in Provence-type books, is coupled with the outsider’s puzzlement at the impenetrability of some aspects of local behaviour.

Dooneen Pier

Grant is not a gifted writer when it comes to scenery: …Trees wore their autumn colours. Streams tumbled down rocks, sparkling… Nevertheless he does slowly build up a picture of a man coming to grips with his place in the natural world and his relationship with animals and the elements. Perhaps the strongest sections of the book are those in which he chronicles the hard work and resourcefulness that it takes to sustain life on a smallholding, the setbacks and difficulties he and Mary encounter, and the support of the neighbours and community without which it would be impossible.

Donald and Mary, although not Catholic, attended the Star of the Sea church in Kilcrohane. This window from that church depicts the struggle against the elements that was such a part of life on the Sheep’s Head

The story of Donald and Mary took a strange turn for me when I decided to Google around a bit, digging for more information about them. Astonishingly, Mary was convicted in Israel in 1956 of spying for Syria! She spent a year in an Israeli prison, eventually applying for a pardon. According to one account, she had fallen for a Syrian diplomat who persuaded her to take photographs in Israel for the Syrians. She was so unsophisticated a spy that she was captured almost right away.

She claimed to have been married to the Syrian: one newspaper account referred to her as Mrs. Caleb Kayali, the former Mary Frances Hagan of Huntington, W. Va. However, Kayali denied that they were married. The trial took place in secret, although the US authorities were kept apprised of the situation. Mary was eventually released when she had served much of her sentence. Once free, she denied that she had been spying, and described her prison term as “boring.”

Donald and Mary on their farm. Note the photographer, Mark Fiennes, who was also living on the Sheep’s Head around this time

She and Donald met when they shared a desk at the United Nations, where they were both correspondents: he for the St. Louis Post-Dispatcher and she for Look Magazine. Little did the people of Doneen know of the chequered history of the American woman who introduced goat’s cheese to their far-flung parish. The story which starts White Goats and Black Bees – the one where Donald and Mary take a sudden notion to move to Ireland and farm – may not have happened quite as related. According to one account, Donald had been “given early retirement” when the Jewish community complained of and investigated what they saw as his “extremely anti-Israel” coverage, and declared that his marriage to a former convicted spy put him in a conflict of interest situation.

The old graveyard in Kilcrohane, centred on a ruined medieval church, is a beautiful and peaceful place

Whatever the truth behind how they got there, Donald and Mary continued to live happily on the Sheep’s Head and eventually in Bantry for the rest of their lives. While Donald died in 1983, Mary lived until 2012. Both are buried in their beloved Kilcrohane.

36 thoughts

  1. Seems in a few years late for this conversation. I was ravenous to learn more about Donald and Mary. I held off investigating until I had finished the book. I felt the sadness of loosing a friend when I did. I moved to Ireland from Canada 16 years ago. So much of what was written still fell close to home almost 50 years later. I just wanted to reach out. When something touches you, you want to share. Thank you all. Its still a personal story, and so worth reading. It was mindfulness, yogic, and true. “I was glad”.

    Liked by 1 person

      • I definitely think you should. I live near ballynahinch where Donald and Mary got their goats. It’s a small world. If I come down your way someday, I’ll bring a pot of honey from my bees. The parallels are delightfully uncanny. 😊


  2. My Great Grandparents were friends with the Grants; whether they knew about their past is a mystery. Also did you ever check out the 26 page JFK file on Donald Grant? It’s most intriguing.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I’m delighted to stumble upon this article. I just discovered the book White Goats & Black Bees among my fathers collection of “back to the land” books that I chose to keep. It seems the property is recently for sale and, as I’m considering an extended stay in Ireland upon retirement, may hold a place in my travels one day!


  4. I love reading this! Mary was my father’s cousin. I remember hearing stories of her time in New York. Then we were sent a copy of their book when it was published. I plan on visiting the area this summer , hopefully I can find her grave and leave flowers.


  5. I so enjoyed this and asked my local bookstore the toadstool to find me a copy of white goats and black bees,which they did ! I’m loving the read , thank you for your continued super writing !


  6. Beautiful photos of Sheep’s Head . On a fine sunny day its as good as it gets anywhere on our planet. Alas for much of the year and in winter its howling gales and Irish desolation . Not a single pub in sight to quench the misery..


  7. I ordered a copy of White Goats Black Bees on Amazon at the time you first mentioned it in this blog. What a fascinating life Mary led before coming to Kilcrohane.


  8. I enjoyed reading this as it reminded me of reading Black Goats when it was first published.It made for great reading as it referenced local characters throughout whom I knew & the impression they made on the Grants.. They sure had us sussed out correctly. Unfortunately I lent the book & never returned as usual.. Thanks for sharing this

    Liked by 2 people

  9. Intriguing stuff Finola, so very interesting..when you originally wrote about this book I had to get a copy and read it, I love these type of books, thank you.

    Liked by 2 people

    • Love this piece Finola. As I may have shared with you, When we moved to Ireland we lived in this home for 2 years, and we lived in it for 6 weeks the year before we moved there.So, for some part of 4 years(2006-2009) we lived in the Dooneen house. We met Mary Grant while living there and the Current owner, Angela Coffee of Tipperary. In all honesty, maybe the best memories of my adult life with my then wife and daughters. It was a “time apart”. This location on the Irish coast alone, is other worldly.Thank you for revisiting this. I shall reblog it today and I may add a few photos that you may not have seen.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.